SquishPixel Blog · SEO · AI search · Analytics and conversion

Randomized trial finds Google AI Overviews cut clicks to websites by about 40%

According to DEV Community, a working paper by Saharsh Agarwal of the Indian School of Business and Ananya Sen of Carnegie Mellon has measured how Google's AI Overviews affect clicks to websites. The study used a randomized design. US desktop Chrome users received a browser extension that hid AI Overviews for one group and left them visible for the other.

Over two weeks of real searches in January and February 2026, with 1,065 participants, the group that saw Overviews averaged 0.37 clicks to outside websites per search. The group that could not see them averaged 0.62. That is a drop of 39.8%. Searches that ended with no outbound click rose from 54% to 73%. A second, separate preregistered experiment with 1,100 people pointed the same way: removing AI Overviews and AI Mode raised publisher clicks.

The article says the loss was concentrated in informational searches, such as the research questions people ask before buying. Across all searches, the authors estimate Overviews cost websites about 18.5% of the organic clicks they get from Google. Organic clicks are the unpaid results. Ad clicks did not change. Bounce rates, quick exits and time on site were also no different between the groups, so the visitors who did click behaved the same way.

The piece also cites DataForSEO, which shows AI Overviews on 61.43% of tracked US keywords in August 2026, up from 5.93% in September 2024. It cites Chartbeat data for the Reuters Institute showing Google search traffic to more than 2,500 news sites down by a third in a year. The article notes the paper is not yet peer-reviewed, covered desktop only and observed people for just two weeks.

Why it matters

For anyone relying on Google for visitors, this is some of the firmest evidence so far that AI answers take clicks away from the sites that wrote the source material. The article stresses that the people who still click are no less engaged. There are simply fewer of them. Because ad clicks stayed flat, the loss falls on unpaid search traffic.

The article says options for recovering the loss are limited. Google's invitation-only pilot is for roughly 100 publishers. Search Console's generative AI performance report shows how often pages appear in AI Overviews and AI Mode, but not clicks or earnings. Evidence that generative engine optimization makes up for the loss is thin. The article's view is that direct relationships with readers, such as newsletters and subscriptions, are a more durable route.

Source: DEV Community. This brief summarises their reporting; read the original for the full detail.